Monday, October 19, 2026

Response to Surveying in Ancient Egypt

 When I first saw the painting, I was very surprised by how bright the colours were and how clearly I could see the details. I even wondered whether it could be a modern forgery. After looking into it, I found that the image seems to be a modern reproduction of an ancient painting. In the upper part, I noticed what looked like knots on a rope, so I guessed that the people might be measuring land. However, I wondered why so many people were around the rope. If it was only being used for measurement, I thought two people might be enough. What were the other people doing?

While reading the article, I was surprised by how many details we seem to know about ancient Egyptian mathematics. The article says that the original provenance of the Moscow Mathematical Papyrus is unknown. This made me wonder how researchers can determine whether it is really an ancient document. Ancient objects have value, and forgeries are possible, so I would like to know what evidence researchers use to verify it. Of course, an unknown provenance does not itself prove that the papyrus is a forgery.

I was also surprised to learn that ancient Egyptians built not only pyramids, but also temples, palaces, and tombs. However, I still wonder how their economy could support the construction of so many large pyramids. This reminded me of the enormous effort and expense involved in transporting a single large stone for the Forbidden City in China, even during the Ming Dynasty. Based on the evidence presented in this article alone, I find it difficult to believe that ancient Egypt could mobilize enough resources for projects on such a scale. What other evidence do we have about how they organized workers, obtained stone, and transported it?

Monday, October 12, 2026

Reflection on Assignment 1: Ancient and Modern Solutions

 Our group project was about finding the volume of a pyramid frustum. We introduced an ancient Egyptian solution based on geometric dissection, compared it with modern methods such as pyramid subtraction and integration, and then gave an extension to the original problem. One thing that I found very meaningful was that the ancient method did not begin with a formula. It divided the frustum into simpler pieces and calculated them separately. Ancient methods often had to rely more on direct geometric ideas because they did not have as many modern mathematical tools. I think this can be especially helpful for students in geometry. It can help them understand why a formula works, instead of only memorizing it.

For the extension part, I explored how the ancient dissection idea could be generalized beyond the square case. While doing this part, I realized that generalization is not simply applying the same conclusion to every similar-looking shape. We need to identify the conditions that make a method work. In this case, the top and bottom faces need to be similar and proportional. This helped me understand that mathematical conclusions are always connected with certain conditions.

After looking at the BC History of Mathematics 11 curriculum, I think this project is closely connected with its learning goals. The curriculum asks students to explore historical geometry, compare multiple strategies, and generalize mathematical ideas. Students could also try a project like this by themselves. As a teacher, I can give some guidance and answer questions while they investigate the problem. In this process, students are not only learning history, but also learning mathematics by doing mathematics.

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Volume of a pyramid frustum Project

 Group Members: Henry Zhao, Eleiah Hengeveld, Kia Prezeau

Problem 1.2.3: Volume of a pyramid frustum

 

Ancient Solution

To complete the problem the ancient way, we must first understand that the old Egyptians often used methods of slicing to break larger area or volume problems into smaller pieces. In particular, their methods were believed to be rooted in geometric dissection; slicing shapes into layers and calculating volume separately, then adding all parts back together for the total. For example, the Egyptians figured out how to calculate the volume of a standard building brick by first finding the area of the base layer (length x width), then interpreting the height measurement as a representation of the number of these layers needed to stack to the top of the brick, thus deriving length x width x height as the volume formula.

As such, the ancient method of calculating the volume of a truncated pyramid is to split the frustum into 9 pieces: the cuboid at the center, the 4 lateral rest prisms, and the 4 small corner pyramids. A figure is labelled below with the side length of the square base (a), the side length of square top (b), the height of the frustum (h), and the side length of the base of the small corner pyramid (x). In particular, it must be noted that x = (a-b)/2, given that the total length (a) of the base can be summed to by taking the side length of the center cuboid with the side length of the bases of 2 small corner pyramids (diagram below).

Untitled_Artwork (2).jpgUntitled_Artwork (3).jpg





Modern Solution

There are a variety of methods to use to solve for the volume of the frustum. The most common or applicable ones are:

-        Pyramid Subtraction

-        Cross-section Integration

-        Triple Integration

-        Divergence Theorem

I’ll only be going over Pyramid Subtraction and Cross-section Integration for sake of brevity.

Pyramid Subtraction


Cross-section Integration

For 


Extension: Generalizing the Ancient Dissection Method

Extension Question

After our team presents the ancient method and the modern method for computing the volume of the original frustum, our extension asks how far the ancient construction can be generalized.

►The key idea is that the dissection does not depend only on the square case.

►If the top and bottom faces are similar and proportional, the same kind of partition can be used for many other frusta.

►In the next two slides, I show this for two families: regular polygon bases and

irregular convex similar polygon bases.

Remark

In fact, a related idea can also be extended to some cases where the top and bottom are not exactly similar. However, that situation branches into many different geometric cases, so for this presentation I only demonstrate the similar and proportional case.

Extension II: Irregular Convex Similar Polygon Bases

These two figures show that the same ancient partition works for a frustum whose top and bottom are similar regular polygons.

The exploded view makes the structure explicit: a central prism together with matching edge pieces and corner pieces.

Extension II: Irregular Convex Similar Polygon Bases

Regularity is not essential: the same construction also works when the two bases are convex, similar, and proportional, even if the polygon is irregular.

So the ancient idea can be understood as a general dissection principle for a much larger class of frusta.

Monday, September 28, 2026

Response to “Did Mesopotamian scribes have algebra?” (Sep 23rd)

 The first point that made me stop was that the core mathematical idea can remain the same even when the notation are different. The Babylonians did not use modern symbols such as x,y, or x^2, but they could still solve equations by using words such as “length,” “breadth,” and “area.” Their methods for solving linear and quadratic equations were very alike to the methods we use today. So, mathematical symbols can be convenient or not, and we can also discuss whether a number system or notation is well designed. However, no matter which notation we use, it should serve the same mathematical logic.

That inspires me the way students learn mathematics now. I think students should also begin by focusing on the principle, instead of paying too much attention to mathematical symbols at the beginning. In my own teaching, I can use more words at first and let students explain what the quantities and relationships mean. After they have a general understanding, I can introduce the corresponding mathematical notation. This does not mean that symbols are not important. Standard notation is necessary because it makes mathematical ideas clearer and easier to communicate. However, if students only memorize symbols and procedures without understanding the meaning behind them, they may not really understand the mathematics.

Market scale puzzle

 


Response to “Babylonian Word Problems”

 The point that made me stop was the article’s discussion of Babylonian word problems and whether they were really practical. I have always thought that mathematics, in its earliest form, was closely connected with practical life. Mathematical ideas developed because people needed to deal with trade, measurement, engineering, accounting, or other economical reasons. However, this article shows that Babylonian mathematics was not only a tool for solving practical problems. Although many of the problems used situations such as grain piles or construction, some of them were clearly too simplified or unrealistic to be used directly in daily work. I think this shows that Babylonian mathematics was becoming more abstract. It was no longer only attached to practical production. It was also used to help students practice mathematical methods and see relationships between quantities from a mathematical aspect.

This also inspired me to think about modern applied word problems. In class, we discussed an example of a teacher who was trying to introduce the idea of proportion by using a problem about interior renovation. One student’s family worked in renovation, and the student had also participated in it before. Therefore, he knew that the proportions in the question could be affected by many different factors. He raised his hand and gave several examples to explain why the problem was not rigorous. If I were the teacher, I would not simply tell him that he was thinking too much and that it was only a simple math question. Instead, I would first praise the student's knowledge, and then explain that the problem was not designed by interior renovation expert to test real renovation knowledge. The question was designed to help students who do not know much about renovation see the proportional relationship between two quantities. I think this kind of answer can respect the student’s real-life knowledge, while also helping him understand why we sometimes use simplified models in mathematics.

Response to Surveying in Ancient Egypt

 When I first saw the painting, I was very surprised by how bright the colours were and how clearly I could see the details. I even wondered...